Professor Jackie Leach Scully
Professor of Social Ethics & Bioethics

  • Email: jackie.scully@ncl.ac.uk
  • Telephone: +44 (0) 191 208 7502
  • Address: PEALS (Policy, Ethics & Life Sciences) Research Centre
    Newcastle University
    4th Floor Claremont Bridge
    Newcastle upon Tyne
    NE1 7RU
    United Kingdom

Introduction

First degree biochemistry, PhD in cellular pathology, followed by research in oncology and neurobiology at research institutes in Switzerland. In 1997 moved to help establish an interdisciplinary unit for bioethics at the University of Basel. Followed research interests in the regulation of genetic and reproductive medicine, and in more general areas of bioethics, disability, the social construction of moral issues, and in feminist and psychoanalytic approaches to understanding moral processes. Between 2002 and 2004 based at Policy, Ethics and Life Sciences Institute at Newcastle, investigating ethical issues in prenatal sex selection. In 2006 returned to Newcastle to join Sociology, and in 2008 joined PEALS as Director of Research.

Roles and Responsibilities

Co-Director, PEALS

Degree Programme Director for Taught Masters degrees 

Qualifications

BA in Biochemistry, University of Oxford, 1985
PhD in Cellular Pathology, University of Cambridge, 1989
MA in Psychoanalytic Theory, Sheffield University, 2008

Previous Positions

Postdoctoral research fellow, Swiss Institute for Experimental Cancer Research, Epalinges
Postdoctoral research fellow, Institute of Physiology, University of Basel
Tutor in Biology, with responsibility for European students, Open University
Lecturer, Institute for Applied Ethics and Centre for Gender Studies, University of Basel
Senior research associate, Unit for Ethics in the Biosciences, University of Basel, Switzerland
Senior Lecturer in Sociology, Newcastle University

Reader in Social Ethics and Bioethics, Newcastle University 

Memberships

International Association for Bioethics
Feminist Approaches to Bioethics Network (Co-coordinator 2008-12, Chair of Congress Organizing Committee 2010-2014)
Swiss Society for Biomedical Ethics
Feminist Ethics and Social Theory
British Sociological Association
American Society for Bioethics and the Humanities

British Association for Human Identification

Languages

English, German, French, and a bit of BSL

Research Interests

Bioethics; moral reasoning and the formation of moral understandings; new reproductive and genetic technologies; neuroscience; disability and embodiment; identification technologies, especially in the context of disaster; feminist bioethics; empirical methodologies.

I have an overarching interest in the development of moral questions, frameworks of understanding, and identities in the bioethical arena. My current research is part of the ‘sociological move’ within bioethics, with a particular focus on new reproductive and genetic technologies, and following a longstanding interest in the responses of socially marginalised groups and religious groups to health and life science developments and policy.

A second, related research area is in the body, and the place of ‘normal’ and ‘anomalous’ embodiment in social and moral life, as well as the effect of biomedical and biotechnological innovations on the relationship between the body and identity. These areas of interest include a substantial amount of work on disability, and more recent activity looking at the socioethics of recovering and identifying human remains, in contemporary and historical contexts. Much of my work uses empirical methodologies.

A large selection of my publications is available to download from Newcastle University's e-Prints service.

Current Work

From 2011-2-14 I was Principal Investigator on an ESRC-funded project, "Faithful Judgements: the role of religion in laypeople's ethical evaluations of new reproductive and genetic technologies" (http://www.ncl.ac.uk/peals/research/project/3979). Together with Dr Jackie Haq (PEALS), Professor Sarah Banks (Durham) and Dr Robert Song (Durham), this study explored the ways in which people who identify as Christian or Muslim deliberate and make bioethical judgements to do with new reproductive and genetic technologies such as egg donation or preimplantation genetic diagnosis. We also investigated the experiences of people of faith in the clinical setting of these technologies, and the opinions of faith group leaders involved in giving guidance on their use.

I am collaborating with colleagues at Northumbria University's Centre for Forensic Studies (NUCFS) in an investigation of the socioethics of forensic identification in mass fatality events, especially but not exclusively the technique of DNA profiling. In December 2012 we convened an expert workshop, with support from the Fondation Brocher, Geneva, "Naming the dead: social, ethical, legal and political issues of disaster victim identification by DNA." This theme was subsequently developed in PEALS 15th Annual International Symposium in April 2014, "Technologies of Identification and Responses to Mass Death", supported with funding by the Wellcome Trust. Part of this interest is being developed through membership of the COST Action "Disaster Bioethics".

I continue to write and research in the general area of embodiment and disability, with a focus on disability as a factor forming moral evaluations and relationships. In this context I am a member of the international consortium "Practices of Responsibility in Change", funded by the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (http://www.nwo.nl/en/research-and-results/research-projects/42/2300181442.html).

Research Roles

Since September 2011 I have been Co-Director with special responsibility for research at the Policy, Ethics and Life Sciences Research Centre of Newcastle University.

Postgraduate Supervision

I would be happy to supervise students in any of the following areas: Bioethics in general, especially ethics of new reproductive and genetic technologies, neuroscience, pharmacogenomics, the pharmaceutical industry; moral reasoning and identity; disability; feminist bioethics; global bioethics.

Currently supervising:
Erica Timoney (self-funded), Falling through the gap: Muslim women and the construction of identities in tension. Supervision with Dr Stephanie Lawler.

Alexis Paton (self-funded), Oncofertility: the experiences of premenopausal breast cancer patients and their health care professionals of fertility preservation discussions. Supervision with Professor Erica Haimes. 

Jacqui Close (ESRC +3 funded), Ideals and expectations: Representations, practices and governance of contemporary motherhood. Supervision with Dr Stephanie Lawler.

Completed:
Rouven Porz (Swiss National Science Foundation), Zwischen Entscheidung und Entfremdung: Patientenperspektiven in der Gendiagnostik und Albert Camus' Konzepte zum Absurden. University of Basel.

Regula Ott (Institute of Biomedical Ethics, University of Zurich, URPP funded), Cognitive neuroenhancement

Michelle Addison (ESRC1+3-funded), The classed and gendered contours of emotional labour. Supervision with Dr Stephanie Lawler. Successfully submitted in June 2014. 

Esteem Indicators and Professional Service

I am Honorary Senior Lecturer in the Faculty of Medicine, University of Sydney, Australia, and was Visiting Professor in the Law Faculty at the University of Technology, Sydney, in November 2013. From September 2012 to January 2013 I was Visiting Professor at the Institute of European Ethnology, Humboldt University, Berlin.

I serve on the Editorial Boards of the International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics, Disability and Society, and Quaker Studies.  I review regularly for a number of journals, including Social Science and Medicine, Sociology of Health and Illness, Bioethics, Disability and Society, and the Journal of Bioethical Inquiry.

I am a member of the ESRC Peer Review College and an International Assessor for the Australian Research Council.

I was an invited member of the Oversight Group for the HFEA's public consultation on prevention of mitochondrial disease in 2012-2013 (http://www.hfea.gov.uk/6896.html), and have been invited to give evidence or opinion to consultations organised by the Nuffield Council of Bioethics, the HFEA, and the Parliamentary Office of Science and technology. I also served on the ethics subcommission of the Swiss Academy for Medical Science which drew up the professional guidelines Behandlung und Betreuung von behinderten Menschen (Treatment and Care of People with Disabilities). 

Recent funding

2011: Naming the dead: social, ethical, legal and political issues of disaster victim identification by DNA. Brocher Foundation, Geneva. Approx. CHF 25,000.

2011: Faithful Judgements: the role of religion in laypeople's ethical evaluations of new reproductive and genetic technologies. ESRC. £215, 954

2011: Known soldiers: the ethics of identifying military remains. School of GPS Research Committee Small Bids Fund. £800.

2009: Parenthood and non-parenthood in an age of assisted conception. British Academy Small Grant, with Dr Stephanie Lawler.

2005-2008: Ethical decisions about the fate of embryos: the views and approaches of couples undergoing IVF. Swiss National Science Foundation grant 1115-65990, Euro 233 917.00, and Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences, Euro 31 550.00.

Projects

Undergraduate Teaching

In academic year 2014-2015 I will be Module Leader for the stage 1 module The Sociological Imagination (SOC1030) and the stage 3 module Sociology of Evil SOC3074.

 

Postgraduate Teaching  

In academic year 2014-2015 I will be giving the MA module SOC8133 Specialist Study on Disability Studies. 

I give input to the Faculty of Medical Sciences MSc in Public Health and Health Services Research, and to the HASS Faculty's Postgraduate Training Programme.