New regulations fail to make TV food adverts healthier for children

Despite new regulations restricting TV advertisements for food, children are still exposed to the same level of advertising for unhealthy products, researchers have found.

Unexpectedly, academics at Newcastle University also found that since the new restrictions were introduced five years ago, viewers of all ages are seeing many more adverts for unhealthy foods which are high in fat, salt and sugar.

In work funded by National Prevention Research Initiative and published today in PLoS ONE, the team describe how they examined the nutritional content of TV ads 6 months before new restrictions were introduced in 2007 and then again 6 months after the full restrictions were put in place in July 2009. They linked this data to how many people saw the adverts and discovered that even after the restrictions were in place, 14.6% of adverts seen were for food and half of those (51.1%) were for less healthy items such as crisps, sugared breakfast cereals and drinks containing large amounts of sugar.

Although almost all adverts shown during children’s programmes adhered to the restrictions, children were still exposed to the same amount of ads for unhealthy foods as they had been before the restrictions – because children don’t just watch children’s programmes.

Dr Jean Adams, Lecturer in Public Health at Newcastle University said: “While adverts stay within the letter of the law, I think we can say we’re still not getting the spirit of the law. These regulations were brought in to help young people make better lifestyle choices and encourage a healthier diet. However, what they are seeing is exactly the same amount of advertising for food which is high in salt or high in sugar and fat as before the regulations came in.

“We know advertising works – otherwise food companies wouldn’t use it - so we have a duty to further tighten up the restrictions particularly if we’re going to help our young people grow up to make good choices about the food they eat.”

The restrictions which have been phased in since April 2007, apply to foods prominently displayed in adverts and include non-alcoholic drinks.  No adverts for foods that are high in fat, salt or sugar can be broadcast during children’s programmes, on children’s channels, or during programmes that are expected to attract a lot of child viewers.  When introduced by Ofcom, the regulations were intended to reduce significantly the exposure of children to television advertising of foods high in fat, salt and sugar and were seen as a step towards improving children's diets and tackling rising levels of obesity.

The research team used information from a national panel of households who record all television that they watch.  Over a one-week period six months before the restrictions were in place there were 104,145 person-minute-views of advertising for food amongst this panel.  Of these 40,233 were for unhealthy food – which is 38.6%. During a full week six months after the restrictions had been fully implemented in 2009, there were 139,959 person-minute-views of food advertising and of this 60.4% was for unhealthy food – or 84,526 person-minute-views.

The prevalence of obesity in the UK has increased markedly over the last 20 years.  In 1993, 12% of men and 16% of women were considered obese.  By 2010 26% of both men and women were classified as obese.  In 2010-11, 11% of boys and 9% of girls in reception year (aged 4-5 years) were obese; whilst 20% of boys and 17% of girls in year 6 (aged 10-11 years) were obese.  By 2050 obesity is predicted to affect 60% of adult men, 50% of adult women and 25% of children.

Responding to the research findings, Dr Kate Allen, Director of Science and Communications at The World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF) , said: “We have always believed that a ban on advertising junk food during children’s TV programming alone is not enough to address rising levels of childhood obesity.

“Children watch programmes other than kids’ TV shows and regulation should be extended to any programme where children make up a significant share of the audience. We would also like regulators to tackle the growth of online advertising and marketing aimed at children as well as areas like sports sponsorship.

“Advertising unhealthy products is a likely cause of childhood obesity which, in later life, can be a contributing factor towards increased cancer risk.”

Mubeen Bhutta, Policy Manager at the British Heart Foundation said: “This research shows that loopholes in advertising regulations allow our children to be targeted with promotions for junk food during their favourite TV shows. Our recent report found that manufacturers are also targeting children online, with promotions for unhealthy foods which can’t be advertised during children’s TV. It’s clear that current restrictions simply don’t go far enough.

“To protect children all junk food adverts should be screened after the 9pm watershed and we want to see consistent advertising regulations across all forms of media, including online, to protect our children. It’s time for the Government to put the health of our children above the health of the advertising industry.”

Reference: Effect of Restrictions on Television Food Advertising to Children on exposure to Advertisements for ‘Less Healthy’ Foods: Repeat Cross-sectional Study, Jean Adams, Rachel Tyrrell, Ashley J Adamson, Martin White. PLoS ONE

published on: 17th February 2012