Staff Profiles
Dr Ilke Turkmendag
Senior Lecturer in Law, Innovation, and Society
- Email: ilke.turkmendag@ncl.ac.uk
- Telephone: +44 (0) 191 208 4342
- Personal Website: http://newcastle.academia.edu/IlkeTurkmendag
- Address: 21-24 Windsor Terrace
Newcastle Law School
Newcastle upon Tyne
NE1 4HQ
United Kingdom
Introduction
I have a PhD in Genetics and Society (Institute for Science and Society and School of Law, University of Nottingham), and a Master’s degree in Science and Technology Studies (University of Oslo).
I am a Senior Lecturer at Law, Innovation, and Society. I am the module leader for Medicine and the Law module at undergraduate level and Research Skills and Methods and Law and Emerging Technologies at postgraduate level. I also teach Medical Device Regulations to postgraduate biomedical engineering and law students.
At the Newcastle Law School, I convene Law and Futures Research Group.
At the Faculty level, I am the Chair of the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences Ethics Committee. I am also the Faculty Lead for Biomedical Engineering NUCoRE .
I am a member of the North of England Medico-Legal Society Council, UK Association for Studies in Innovation, Science and Technology, and AHRC Peer Review College.
Background
My doctoral work concerned the social and ethical implications of the removal of donor anonymity from gamete donors in the UK. I explored the reactions of would-be parents to this legal shift through semi-structured interviews and a virtual ethnography study on an online patient support group.
After the completion of my doctoral work, I joined the Policy, Ethics and Life Sciences Research Centre (PEALS) at Newcastle University, which has provided me with a deep understanding in evidence based bioethics. Between January 2010-2012, I was a Post Doctoral Research Associate in 'Interdisciplinary Approaches to the Uses of Reproductive Tissue in Stem Cell Science', a project led by Professor Erica Haimes.
In 2011, I was granted a Mildred Blaxter Postdoctoral Fellowships funded by the Foundation of Sociology of Health and Illness to disseminate the findings from my PhD thesis.
http://www.shifoundation.org.uk/?page_id=174
After completion of my fellowship, in February 2014, I joined Sheffield University to help coordinating the activities towards preparing large grant applications, as well as developing my own grant proposals with Professor Paul Martin. I also taught 'Social Theory and Analysis' and 'Sociology of the New Genetics'. In Sheffield I also coordinated the activities of the Biosociety Network and played role in launching a new university research centre, iHuman.
In February 2016, I joined the Newcastle Law School.
Memberships
- Arts and Humanities Research Council Peer Review College Member (appointed December 2019)
- Socio-Legal Studies Association (SLSA) Executive Committee and Grants Committee (appointed September 2017) https://www.slsa.ac.uk/index.php/executive-committee (2017-2019)
- North of England Medico-Legal Society Council Member (appointed October 2019) http://www.nemls.co.uk/council-members/
- Higher Education Academy (Fellow, June 2018)
- Association for Studies in Innovation Science and Technology (ASSIST UK)
- Association for Responsible Research and Innovation in Genome Editing (ARRIGE)
- International Genome Editing Network (University of Lisbon, University of Oxford)
- Northern Bioethics Network
- Northern Empirical Legal Studies Group
- European Association for the Study of Science and Technology
Qualifications
PhD, The Institute for Science and Society and School of Law, University of Nottingham. (Awarded July 2009)
‘The Removal of Donor Anonymity in the United Kingdom: The Silencing of Claims by Would-be Parents’ (Awarded 07.2009)
Supervised by Prof Robert Dingwall and Prof Therese Murphy
MA, European Studies of Society, Science and Technology, The Centre for Technology, Innovation and Culture (TIK), University of Oslo, Norway. (Awarded 12.2003)
‘Embryo in the Parliament: The British Parliament Debate on the Embryo Technology’.
Supervised by Prof Torben Nielsen
Bachelor of Business Administration, Faculty of Political Science, Ankara University, Turkey. (Awarded February 1997)
Teaching qualifications
Fellow of Higher Education Academy.
Newcastle Teaching Award, June 2018.
Previous Positions
- Research Associate, Department of Sociological Studies, Sheffield University
- Mildred Blaxter Post-Doctoral Fellow, PEALS, Newcastle University
- Post-Doc Research Associate PEALS, Newcastle University
- Part-Time Teacher, University of Nottingham
- Senior Resident Tutor University of Nottingham
- Senior Financial Auditor, KPMG, Istanbul
Research
I have two main areas of research interests. The first is the socio-legal and ethical issues associated with biomedicine, and the second focuses on the regulation of emerging medical technologies. Owing to my background, I bring a distinctive interdisciplinary approach to my research which enables me to apply insights and perspectives from science and technology studies, bioethics, and law.
Current Research
Ethics of Anti-Ageing: I am interested in one area of anti-aging research concerns ‘longevity’, which is the length of the life span independent of the biological ageing process. I examine the everyday longevity protocols disseminated on social media and their ethical implications for managing personal health.
You can find my podcast about ethics of healthy ageing here:
Mason Institute Investigates Episode 7: Longevity for me, but not for thee? Longevity protocols and the ethics of healthy ageing.
Epigenetics and law: I am interested in the ways in which developments in epigenetics research influence how maternal responsibility and rights are perceived. In line with that, my recent research focuses on the ways in which the claims associated with epigenetics may give rise to legal claims. I was awarded British Academy/Leverhulme Trust Small Grant SRG18R1\180531 to explore this: ‘Sins of the mother: Socio-legal imaginaries of epigenetics’. (01/05/2019-28/02/2021)
Project website: Sins of the Mother: Socio-legal Imaginaries of Epigenetics
Human genome editing: I am interested in the social, regulatory, and ethical aspects of human germline editing. In this context, I particularly focus on the meaning and limits of reproductive autonomy, and how our reproductive decisions may affect future generations.
Past research
In the past, I explored the social, ethical, and legal aspects of gamete donation, and focused on right-to-know claims by donor-conceived adults and the cross border reproductive care movements by the would-be parents who wanted to avoid the law or the long waiting lists in the UK. I disseminated most of my findings under the Mildred Blaxter Postdoctoral Fellowships funded by the Foundation of Sociology of Health and Illness http://www.shifoundation.org.uk/?page_id=174
Following the completion of my postdoctoral research on donor conception and cross border reproductive care movements, I examined the public debate on the novel mitochondrial replacement techniques, and the construction of rights in the regulatory process. With a small team of lawyers and bioethicists I have conducted a pilot project to examine the ethical, legal, and social implications of new health technologies, involving the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Following this, I was a Co-Investigator in an ESRC/BBSRC funded project on epigenetics: EpiStressNet: A biosocial systems approach to understanding the epigenetic embedding of social stress responses: http://gtr.rcuk.ac.uk/projects?ref=ES/N000528/1
To date, my research has been published in leading international peer-reviewed journals and as book chapters in high-profile edited collections resulting from research council-funded (ESRC and AHRC) projects. I also act as a referee for numerous journals including the Journal of Medical Ethics, New Genetics and Society, Reproductive Biomedicine Online, Human Reproduction, Sociology of Health and Illness, Biosocieties, and Bioethics and as a peer reviewer for the Wellcome Trust, ESRC, AHRC, Fonds voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek-Vlaanderen (FWO), Belgium, and Czech Science Foundation.
PhD Supervision
I would be interested in supervising projects within my research interests as outlined below, but students who are interested in other areas of biomedicine and human reproduction are also welcome to contact me.
- Socio-ethical issues around healthy ageing, longevity research and self-tracking technologies.
- Human reproduction technologies,
- Fertility treatment
- Reproductive autonomy
- Reproductive tissue donation
- Child's 'right-to know' in donor conception and mitochondrial replacement techniques
- Cross border reproductive care (CBRC) movements
- Epigenetics and maternal responsibility
- Socio-legal and ethical issues around the human genome editing techniques
- Medical device and implants
- Abortion and assisted human reproduction, including surrogacy
Completed PhD Supervision:
Ying-Qi Liaw, A Child-Centered Approach in Human Heritable Germline Editing
Current Students:
Jinshuo Liu, The Legal Status of Frozen Embryos and Disputes over their Disposition: An International Perspective
Undergraduate Teaching
LAW 3024 Medicine and the Law (Module leader) (2016- present)
LAW 3098 Dissertation (2017-2018)
LAW 1110 Legal Institutions and Method (2017-2018)
LAW 8152 Theory and Methods of Research (Module leader) (2016-2019)
Postgraduate Teaching
LAW 8090 Legal Research Skills and Methods (Module leader) (2017-present)
MEC 8056 Medical Device Regulations (2019- present)
Law 8577 Law and Emerging Technologies (2022- present)
-
Articles
- Turkmendag I, Liaw Ying-Qi. Maternal epigenetic responsibility: What can we learn from the pandemic?. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 2022, Epub ahead of print.
- Martin P, Turkmendag I. Thinking the unthinkable: how did human germline genome editing become ethically acceptable?. New Genetics and Society 2021, 40(4), 384-405.
- Liaw Y-Q, Turkmendag I, Hollingsworth K. Reinterpreting “genetic identity” in the regulatory and ethical context of heritable genome editing. New Genetics and Society 2021, 40(4), 406-424.
- Martin P, Morrison M, Turkmendag I, Nerlich B, McMahon A, de Saille S, Bartlett A. Genome editing: the dynamics of continuity, convergence and change in the engineering of life. New Genetics and Society 2020, 39(2), 219-242.
- Mackenzie L, Turkmendag I, Burr-Raty I, Hunter W, Jarvis C, Simun M, Tapio H, Zretsky A. Body Shopping challenging convention in the donation and use of bodily materials through art practice. Journal of Technoetic Arts 2020, 18(2-3), 279-297.
- Turkmendag I, Fox M, Thompson C, Murphy T. What’s Law got to do with Good Science?. Social and Legal Studies 2019, 28(3), 392-413.
- Turkmendag I. It is just a 'battery': 'Right' to know in mitochondrial replacement. Science, Technology and Human Values 2018, 43(1), 56-85.
- Hewitt M, Dingwall R, Turkmendag I. Squeeze on academics poses threats to learned societies. Research Fortnight 2017, 23-23.
- Hewitt M, Dingwall R, Turkmendag I. More than research intermediaries: a descriptive study of the impact and value of learned societies in the UK Social Sciences. Science and Public Policy 2017, 44(6), 775-788.
- Murphy T, Turkmendag I. Kinship: Born and Bred (But also Facilitated)? A Commentary on 'Donor Conception: Ethical Aspects of Information Sharing' (Nuffield Council on Bioethics, London 2013). Medical Law Review 2014, 22(3), 422-433.
- Turkmendag I. The Donor-conceived Child's `Right to Personal Identity': The Public Debate on Donor Anonymity in the United Kingdom. Journal of Law and Society 2012, 39(1), 58-75.
- Turkmendag I. Home and Away: The Turkish Ban on Donor Conception. Law, Innovation and Technology 2012, 4(2), 144-164.
- Haimes E, Taylor K, Turkmendag I. Eggs, ethics and exploitation? Investigating women's experiences of an egg sharing scheme. Sociology of Health and Illness 2012, 34(8), 1199-1214.
- Turkmendag I, Dingwall R, Murphy T. The Removal of Donor Anonymity in the United Kingdom: The Silencing of Claims by Would-be Parents. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 2008, 22(3), 283-310.
-
Book Chapters
- Turkmendag I. Exploitation and Control of Women’s Reproductive Bodies. In: Wendy A. Rogers, Jackie Leach Scully, Stacy M. Carter, Vikki Entwistle, Catherine Mills, ed. The Routledge Handbook of Feminist Bioethics. Routledge, 2022.
- Turkmendag I. The voice of silence: UK patients’ silent resistance to the assisted reproduction regulations. In: Cloatre, E; Pickersgill, M, ed. Knowledge, Technology and Law: At the Intersection of Socio-Legal and Science & Technology Studies. London, UK: Routledge, 2015.
- Turkmendag I. When sperm cannot travel: Experiences of UK would-be parents seeking treatment abroad. In: Flear, M.L., Farrell, A.M., Hervey, T.K., Murphy, T, ed. European Law and New Health Technologies. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2013, pp.362-380.
-
Digital or Visual Media
- Turkmendag I. Longevity for me, but not for thee? Longevity protocols and the ethics of healthy ageing. https://media.ed.ac.uk/media/Mason+Institute+Investigates+Episode+7A+Longevity+for+me%2C+but+not+for+theeF+Longevity+protocols+and+the+ethics+of+healthy+ageing./1_jdoybrt0: University of Edinburgh, 2023.
-
Online Publications
- Turkmendag I. Sins of ‘Women of Childbearing Age’. University of Birmingham, 2021. Available at: http://slsablog.co.uk/blog/blog-posts/sins-of-women-of-childbearing-age/.
- Turkmendag I. Blog: Epigenetics, Blaming Mothers, and the Law. Newcastle: Newcastle University, 2021. Available at: https://www.ncl.ac.uk/law/research/funded/epigenetics/.
- Turkmendag I, Murphy T. What's law got to do with human germline editing?. Social and Legal Studies, 2019. Available at: https://socialandlegalstudies.wordpress.com/2019/07/12/whats-law-got-to-do-with-human-germline-editing/.
- Turkmendag I. Heritable genome editing ‘morally permissible’ but will require ‘international consensus’. LNB News, 2018. Available at: https://www.lexisnexis.com/uk/legal/.
- Taylor K, Turkmendag I, Wienroth M, Woods S. PEALS and NLS Response to Call for Evidence held by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics on Genome editing. 2017. Available at: http://nuffieldbioethics.org/wp-content/uploads/PEALS-NLS-response-to-NCoB-2017-05-30.pdf.
- Woods S, Scully JL, McCormack P, Turkmendag I. Response to report by Nuffield Council on Bioethics, Give and take? Human bodies in medicine and research: consultation summary. London: Nuffield Council on Bioethics, 2010. Available at: http://nuffieldbioethics.org/wp-content/uploads/Simon-Woods-Jackie-Leach-Scully-Pauline-McCormack-and-Ilke-Turkmendag-of-the-Policy-Ethics-and-Life-Sciences-Research-Centre.pdf.
-
Report
- Dingwall R, Hewitt I, Turkmendag I. Evaluation of Learned Societies Project 2014. May 2014, Academy of Social Sciences. 2014.
-
Reviews
- Turkmendag I. Review of ‘New Organs Within Us: Transplants and the Moral Economy (Experimental Futures)’. Sanal, A., Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2011. Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 2012, 7(1), 81-82.
- Turkmendag I. Banchoff, T. Embryo Politics: Ethics and Policy in Atlantic Democracies. USA: Cornell University Press, 2011, £22.95 (hbk) viii+294pp, ISBN: 9780801449574. Sociology of Health and Illness 2012, 34(4), 646-647.
- Ozdemir I. Book Review: John R. Spencer and Antje Du Bois-Pedain (eds), Freedom and Responsibility in Reproductive Choice. Social & Legal Studies 2008, 17(3), 409-410.